A 4th grade teacher and I were experimenting with notebook entries during a unit on narrative writing.
One of the teacher’s concerns was the students’ selection of detail. It seemed they did not know which details were okay to leave out of their stories. She had noticed that students often included unnecessary detail, which resulted in “bed-to-bed” stories that lacked focus. How, she wondered, could we get them to write more focused narratives? And what types of entries could they make in their writer’s notebooks to help them with this process?
One of the instructional strategies we tried was to have them write their “hot spot” first. The hot spot is the climax of the story, the most exciting part, the crescendo. Before we wrote any of our other notebook entries, we wrote our hot spots. It was the first bit of writing we did after choosing our topics. This was a new way to enter into the narrative for us.
Here is my notebook entry from my imagined narrative about a Halloween when my two daughters actually became their Halloween costumes.
(The bottom of the page shows a revision technique. Choose one sentence, circle it, and on the bottom of the page, write 3 more sentences off of it to add detail.)
The results of having the students write their hot spots first were positive. After reviewing their final drafts, the classroom teacher and I noticed that:
- There were very few bed-to-bed stories.
- The hot spots were described with sufficient detail and specificity. We attributed the depth of detail to both writing the hot spot first and also the use of the revision technique of “Add 3 More” (seen in my notebook entry above.)
- The hot spot was easily identified by the reader.
We were pleased with the results. Writing the hot spot first is one way to enter into a narrative.
I sure like the idea of circling a sentence and then writing three more sentences to give more details. Stealing it, of course…
LikeLike
Great thoughts Dana. I may also try this in my own writing. A friend of mine just did this very thing and also had great results. Nice post!
LikeLike
I’m going to try writing the hot spot first in my own writing. I think I (and many writers) often get so caught up trying to write the perfect introduction that we lose it once we get to the climax of the story. What an important lesson for us all!
LikeLike
This is awesome! Thanks for sharing! I will use this next week to help my students get much more focused
LikeLike
I love this Dana. Coincidentally, I was just discussing this with my students TODAY. Details and the time frame of events in a narrative… my students were critiquing a mentor text and didn’t appreciate how the climax was so brief, “He died then, Bam. Over,” I think were the exact words of my student, Andrew. Yes. yes, and yes. I am trying this this week.
LikeLike
I’m liking this idea. As teachers we should constantly be looking for ways to encourage writing and give positive feedback. Thank you for sharing.
LikeLike
Love it! Thanks for sharing!
LikeLike
It does work! We are currently finishing up our hot spot. By the way…I used your entry as one of my models 🙂
LikeLike
I am going to try that with my own writing, like you did in your notebook. Sometimes I just don’t know what my story is really revolving around – this will really help. Thanks!!
LikeLike
Great tip Dana! This will really help young writers to stretch out the heart of their stories and to push for deeper meaning right from the start. Nice 🙂
LikeLike
I love the idea of circle a sentence and then write three more. Great way to dig into a story for detail. Thanks.
LikeLike
Thanks for this idea. I will definitely apply it with my students. I get tired of reading personal narratives that start with first and go on to then, then, and then. Some of our writing tools become good writing killers. This is true for sequencing words. Starting with a “hot spot” will surely help them get away from this and help them write more interesting stories.
LikeLike