I’ve heard Lucy Calkins say that the mark of a great writing conference is that the writer leaves with increased energy for writing. A great comment on someone’s Slice of Life story can do the same. Learning to compliment others well is a real art. Receiving any kind of positive feedback on one’s writing feels great. Receiving a compliment that gets at the heart of what one was trying to do as a writer feels amazing.
Teach your students to leave compliments for others that point out specific writing moves that they themselves are attempting to master. You might reference some of your teaching charts that list qualities of good narrative writing and ask students to turn these into specific compliments that might benefit other writers. You might generate a list of such compliments, for example:
- I love how you start with a few lines of dialogue (or a small action) that put us right into the middle of the story.
- You paint such a clear picture of the scene. I can imagine exactly the kind of place where your story occurs.
- Your bring out such strong emotions in your story through the dialogue and the way you describe people’s actions and reactions.
- I can tell that this moment had a lot of meaning for you. Even though at first glance it seems like just a story about ______, I can tell that for you, it was really a story about_______.
- I can really relate to the experience you write about in your story because the way you tell it makes it feel universal. For example, …
If you have other compliments that speak to qualities of good narrative writing, feel free to add them to this list.
NB: After I had drafted this post and got it ready to be published today, I noticed Tara posted about how to leave constructive comments just the night before. Great minds think alike! Check out her lovely tips here.
Happy Slicing!
Useful Links:
- 31 Slices (ideas for topics)
- Essential Information (includes classroom materials, details on Twitter hashtags, and thoughts about commenting)
- Q&A About the Classroom Slice of Life Story Challenge (watch a video call with elementary school students)
Alternative high school, teacher needs to improve on this late online entry…
http://wfcwrites.wordpress.com/2014/03/06/day-2-of-31/
LikeLike
This is my first time doing this! I hope some of your students can come comment of my students’ blogs! It will be so exciting for them!
http://kidblog.org/ELLBlock2/category/slice-of-life-march-challenge/
LikeLike
Day #4 – Pay attention, notice and compliment others actions ~ not just writing. http://islandsofmysoul.com/2014/03/05/notice-name-it-and-pay-a-compliment/
LikeLike
Day 4: This will grow tomorrow as posts written tonight are added to the blog during the day.
http://carrskiddos.weebly.com/2/post/2014/03/slice-of-life-day-4.html
LikeLike
Here is the link to my students’ blogs: http://kidblog.org/EastCentralWriters/
LikeLike
Here’s day 4 for our first graders:
http://merelylearningtogether.weebly.com/1/post/2014/03/slice-of-life-day-4.html
LikeLike
Well, this doesn’t happen every day.
http://theleadgoose.blogspot.com/2014/03/slice-of-life-4-i-burped-in-class.html
LikeLike
My fifth graders are participating in a modified way. They don’t have individual blogs, so their slicing in their notebooks. I’ll ask permission several times a week to scan and post a few on our classroom blog. This is our first link up today! http://muellersreaders.blogspot.com/2014/03/5th-grade-slice-of-life-challenge.html
LikeLike
Day 4 6th Grade Slices, Missouri
http://slicesfrompod2.blogspot.com/2014/03/march-4th-slices.html
LikeLike
I’m not sure if it works best to link up at the end of the day when lots of posts have been submitted, or if that matters. So proud of my students for slicing during two snow days.
http://kidblog.org/MrsKeelersRLAclass/
LikeLike
The kids are really excited to read everyones ‘slices’. I’m wanting them to read more posts to be exposed to even more writing and we love interacting with other classes! I know they’d love the comments and we love commenting on others as well!
http://kidblog.org/301bloggers/
LikeLike
I’m going to have to teach students to link up. Yesterday I went to sleep before they’d posted. Teenagers! Here’s Mariangel writing about chocolate today: http://31students.wordpress.com/2014/03/04/march-4th-2014/
LikeLike
I forgot to link up. I hope some of you will come back tomorrow. I have a former student who has joined us for the SOLC. She is writing some wonderful poetry. http://kidblog.org/SliceofLifeChallenge/
LikeLike
First graders loving the challenge!
http://www.behindthescenesinfirstgrade.com/our-blogfirst-grade-speaks-out.html
LikeLike
Wow. My HS ELLs are loving the comments! Thanks so much for encouraging your students to comment! We will return the favor soon — we are in the midst of a big project until Thursday! Still lots of excellent slices so far though!
http://kidblog.org/WritingOurOwnWords/tag/slice-of-life/
LikeLike
Our first link since March and snow days! http://tklingerfirstgradematters.blogspot.com/2014/03/reflections-of-our-weekend-solc14-1.html
LikeLike
Eden’s pets http://fromourkingzoo.blogspot.com/2014/03/me-and-my-pets.html
LikeLike
My first graders!
http://kidblog.org/2014-2/
LikeLike
I love the tips and also referred to Tara’s post. I think that is a great thing to do in this community. xo
LikeLike
That’s great! Thanks so much.
LikeLike
Here we are – day 4 (day 2 for us) – thank you to those who have commented. I have my settings open to the world, but if you have trouble, please sign in as Guest, password Guest. Thanks so much!
http://kidblog.org/MrsRogersBloggers13-14/ and http://kidblog.org/MrsRogersBloggers13-14II/
LikeLike
Third grade slices will be coming in throughout the day.
http://3rdgradeslicers.wordpress.com/2014/03/04/solsc-2/
LikeLike
Trying to get my students out to comment on as many classes as we can this week! I know they really love getting comments from people.
http://kidblog.org/writingtigers/
LikeLike
Hope that you enjoy our Day 4 Slicers from The International School of Kuala Lumpur! Take care. http://iskl6aslicers.blogspot.com/2014/03/meeting-meetings-my-pet-peeveff.html
LikeLike
Goode morning! Day 4: March in Texas. http://wp.me/p4nsSb-c
LikeLike
Here are our slices for today! 🙂
http://mskimgrade5.blogspot.sg/2014/03/slice-of-life-challenge-day-4.html
LikeLike
Today’s sixth grade slices. Enjoy!
LikeLike
Here is the link to Max and Kam’s 6-8th grade class at The Logan School in Denver, CO. http://maxsclassreads.blogspot.com/2014/03/solsc-3414-max-and-kams-class.html
LikeLike
Hi – Here is the link to 6B Slicers posts for Day 4. Thanks!
http://6bslicers.blogspot.com/2014/03/slice-of-life-4.html
LikeLike